By Lee Stace

ONE THING that has become painfully evident since news broke that the Otago Rugby Union will cease trading on Friday due to its inability to service debt of more than $2 million dollars is a lack of accountability.

As was the case when Rugby Southland struck serious financial trouble at the tail-end of 2010, no-one has been prepared to put their hand up and admit fault for the union’s current state of affairs.

Make no mistakes about it. The problems at the 131-year-old ORU are not new. It has been struggling financially for a number of seasons, but it is only now that we know the full extent of its problems.

So far we have been told that it was a combination of factors that have led Otago to this point. Silly business decisions and poor fiscal management – to the point where the principles of basic economics (that is, don’t spend more than you earn) had become a forgotten art – have all played a part.

All of which leads us to ask the most obvious questions: where is the accountability and who is responsible?

The blame clearly lies with those who have been or were running the ORU ship in recent times, even if the New Zealand Rugby Union says it is pointless pointing fingers because it won't change the current situation.

That might be true, but the passionate and good rugby people of Dunedin and its surrounding areas have every right to know exactly how their union has got to the point where it can no longer trade as a business. They have every right to know the names of those were making and signing off on the poor business decisions that have ultimately seen the ORU dig itself into a massive financial hole.

Moreover, those people in charge or who were responsible for the running of the union should have the decency to come forward and own up to their mistakes.

Sadly, though, that appears unlikely to happen.

The current board is blaming decisions made by previous administrations and former ORU baord members do not wish to comment.

None more so than the ORU’s former chief executive, Richard Reid, who refused to speak on the situation in January after it was revealed in the Sunday Star-Times that the union had axed staff and sold any assets that weren't nailed down to the floor as part of its cost-cutting measures –despite those measures being the direct result of some bad business decisions made during his tenure in charge.

“I don't work there anymore. It's up to the board to comment,” said Reid. “You'll have to do your own digging.”

Former All Blacks coach Laurie Mains resigned from the ORFU board earlier this month and was also reluctant to comment on financial matters. So too was Ron Palenski, the ORU chairman between 2003-10.

The current board members will walk away from this mess when the clock strikes 4pm on Friday, free to sit on other boards or take over the running of different companies.

Where is the justice and fairness in that?

As far as bailouts go, the New Zealand Rugby Union is right not to come up with a rescue package. Like any business operating in this tough economic climate, it has its own financial problems to deal with and simply cannot afford to take on Otago’s as well.

Likewise for the New Zealand Government, whose priority it is to use taxpayer money to fund key infrastructure projects and public services, not help private companies out of self-inflicted financial jams.

Posted Comments

Great article.
Al Little
I agree with the NZRU its no good pointing the finger at the decision makers, the problem is the decisions made, they alienated there fan base, students cant afford a ticket and then get charged $7 for a beer, just one example, students are there fan base they need to cater to them, im not saying let them burn couches in the stand but reverse some of the decisions that turned them away and you will get back the 10,000 to 15,000 crowds of the past, stop listening to the Dunedin wowser rate payers they will never come back.
Very sad for all the players and fans who have passionately invested in their team for over 130 years. But its no surprise in today's economic rationalist world of mentality. Clearly results, or striving for them, were more important than maintaining a sensible budget and building the team back up over time and this is the result. There seems to be no 'accountability' at any level. Very, very sad.
I agree with everything you say in this article and hope that once again, after problems in Otago Rugby we do not have a secret report and are then told 'nothing to see here ...lets move on...' However, in no way lessening the board and administrations roles in this debacle I think there requires wider thought. Patently the NZRFU had its own impact on this situation. New Zealand cannot afford 19 professional rugby teams... the financial problems facing many Unions are a direct result of their decisions to expand the first division.
What ball is played with this sport soccer.
You are allowed only 100 words for comments.
Your have 100 words left.

We at and NZ Rugby News Ltd like to keep our readers up to date with the latest news, offers from our sites and information from our partners. We are committed to protecting your privacy and will not pass your details on to any company outside of our network.

We at NZ Rugby News Ltd invite our readers (you) to post comments on the blogs on our website. Please read our terms and conditions below.

Please note the views which are expressed in the comment areas are not our views, nor the views of any of our staff. We accept no liability in respect to any material posted in the comments areas and are not responsible for the content and accuracy of that material.

If you place reliance on material posted in the comments area, you do so at your own risk, and you indemnify us from any liabilities, claims, costs, loss (including consequential loss) or damage suffered or caused by doing so.

If you comment on our blogs, the following terms and conditions apply.

Our rights

We retain the right (but not the obligation) to edit, delete, reject or remove any comment which you post or want to post in our blog areas.

You grant us non-exclusive, royalty-free, perpetual, worldwide licence to republish any material you submit to us, without limitation, in any format.

We retain the right to terminate your ability to comment on our blogs if we believe you are abusing the service in any way, or have breached these terms and conditions.

You consent to our collecting and storing your email and IP address for security purposes and you will also receive a complementary subscription to RugbyEnews.

Your obligations

You will not be able to post the following comments on our blogs:

(a) Anything which is not an original work or infringes upon the copyright, registered trademark or intellectual property rights of another person;

(b) Anything which is or could be deemed to be obscene, offensive, pornographic, vulgar, profane, indecent or otherwise illegal;

(c) Anything which is defamatory towards a person, company or organisation.

(d) Anything which racially or religiously vilifies, incites violence or hatred, or is likely to offend, insult or humiliate others based on race, religion, ethnicity, gender, age, sexual orientation or any physical or mental disability;

(e) Anything which you know or suspect is false, misleading or deceptive.

(f) Anything which advertises or promotes goods, services and products in a commercial manner; or

(g) Anything which provides financial advice or advice of any kind to any financial product.



You agree to fully indemnify and hold us harmless against any liabilities, claims, costs, loss (including consequential loss) or damage incurred as a result of any comments you post in our blog area, or as a result of any breach by you of these terms and conditions.

Notwithstanding any indemnity provided by you under these terms and conditions, we retain the right to assume the conduct of any defence to a claim brought against us and of any proceedings or appeal issued by us, and you agree to provide all reasonable cooperation (including making relevant documents available) that we may require from you in relation to any such claim, proceeding or appeal.

These terms and conditions shall be construed and applied in accordance with the laws of New Zealand, and you consent to the exclusive jurisdiction of the New Zealand Courts to determine any matter or dispute which arises under these terms and conditions in accordance with the laws of New Zealand.

Upcoming Matches

2014 Super Rugby fixtures

2014 Super Rugby fixtures

All the fixtures you need to plan your viewing pleasure!

Fixtures & Results

Super Rugby
Heartland Championship
Rugby World Cup 2011


Mark Calverley Super Rugby - Not going to plan for NZ teams. Should we worry?

Not all our own way for NZ teams

By Mark Calverley

Mark Calverley Benji - Should he stay or should he go?

Pressure is on Benji, but shouldn't we remember SBW went to France (Toulon) for 2 years to learn the game.

By Mark Calverley

Mark Calverley Concussion

With all of the news around concussion do you think there should be safety measures in place for players to ensure they don't play on after a head know? How and who should police that?

By Mark Calverley

Mark Calverley Club Rugby - How to get the MOJO back

With the start of club rugby upon us, how can we maintain the value of the clubs in player pathways and community spirit.

By Mark Calverley